Monday, 20 January 2014

Computing: A busy year ahead for schools

Computing: A busy year ahead for schools

The countdown is well under way towards the new computingcurriculum. Bob Harrison considers the challenges facing schools in 2014 – both with computing and wider use of technology – and discusses the support available for computing to help schools hit the ground running in September. 

General-ICTComputer2.gif
Last year saw a seismic shift in the ICT national curriculum as it was morphed into computing at the behest of education minister Elizabeth Truss following lobbying from, and then co-operation with, the British Computer Society and the Royal Academy of Engineering.
Despite the criticism of the wider ICT education community, the broader IT industry and a curious drafting process and public consultation where concerns were expressed about the in-balance between the three core elements of ICT – digital literacy, information technology, and computer science – teachers are now faced with what is virtually a new subject, the core of which is essentially computer science.
But all that is water under the bridge now as teachers have returned to school and are planning their annual education technology binge (known as the Bett Show) later this month.
As the countdown to implementation in September continues, they will be more concerned with how they and their colleagues can ensure they have the subject knowledge, confidence and capability to teach what is essentially a new subject at all key stages.
Headteachers and heads of ICT will be reminded at Bett that they also have another challenge in addition to the new national curriculum – the constant challenge of ensuring that teachers of all subjects can make the most effective use of the ever-changing technologies coming on to the market to enhance and improve teaching and learning.
Martin Bean, the vice-chancellor of the Open University, described this challenge at a recent conference as “the growing crisis of relevance facing our schools and colleges”. 
He was of course alluding to the gap between the daily lives of our children, young people and adult learners who are immersed in the daily use of digitaltechnology and the pot luck of whether that same technology will be being effectively used in the school, college, university or training provider of their choice (if they have a choice!).
There is plenty of help and support available for teachers to deliver the newcomputing national curriculum, but has the use of technology across thecurriculum (known as technology-enhanced learning or TEL) largely been sidelined by the focus on computing?
For the head of ICT, it will be a case of competing priorities and scarce resources. Traditionally the head of ICT has had responsibility for the teaching/assessment of the national curriculum subject, the use of ICT in other subjects across the curriculum, management of technical/technician support, and a leading role in the procurement and replacement of equipment.
The delivery and assessment of the national curriculum is a legal requirement in state schools (unless it is an academy, free school, studio school or university technical college). Whereas the use of technology in English, geography, science and so on is a decision related to the teaching and learning strategies of the subject, and surely that responsibility lies with the lead for that particular subject and is steered by the vision, leadership, culture and strategies for teaching, learning and assessment.

Computing – help and support

For those teachers, especially in the primary phase but at secondary level too, who are anxious about the subject knowledge required to be ready for September 2014 and the new computing curriculum, there is plenty of help available.
The British Computer Society (BCS) has received more than £3 million in grants to extend its volunteer network of “Computing at Schools” and has begun to recruit up to 400 “master teachers” who, once trained, will be released from their own schools so others can buy them in to delivercomputing CPD.
The subject knowledge and understanding of primary teachers has been a cause for concern and this is an area that could obviously have a knock-on effect on the challenges facing secondary schools as pupils move through the system.
To support primary colleagues, the Department for Education (DfE) has announced a number of initiatives to support schools. These include three-day training courses with a contribution to supply cover costs and a recently launched “barefoot computing” initiative which will also provide additional learning opportunities for teachers.
Elsewhere, the DfE has also funded generous bursaries of up to £25,000 for new teachers entering teacher education programmes in computing. Details of all these initiatives can be found on the Computing at Schools website (see further information).

A resource by teachers for teachers

One of the most successful initiatives to support the introduction of the newcomputing curriculum has come from teachers themselves. A Google site (see further information) “created by teachers for teachers” has resources, links, skills audits and CPD opportunities and continues to provide welcome advice and support for teachers at all key stages (despite the DfE withdrawing funding).
More than 30 teachers and teacher educators freely give their time and share their expertise on the site to help other teachers to deliver the new curriculum
As Sian Bloor, a teacher of ICT in Trafford, said: “I wouldn’t have known how to start teaching the new computing curriculum without the resources and links on the site.”
Another network of support comes from Naace, which provides advice, support, programmes and conferences for the whole of the new computingcurriculum. Its events are particularly welcome as they include a focus on IT and digital literacy, not just the computer science element. 
Paul Hynes, deputy head of George Spencer High School in Nottingham – a leading Teaching School for ICT and computing, said at a recent conference: “The £100 membership fee for Naace is probably the best £100 the school has ever spent.”

New curriculum review body

The reform of the ICT curriculum was long overdue. Partly because of the pace of technological change but also because it had not been refreshed since the early 2000s. 
It is vital that this kind of delay does not happen again and a new body, the UK Forum for Computing Education, has been established by the Royal Academy of Engineering to help prevent this. 
One of its jobs is to keep the new computing curriculum programmes of study under constant review to ensure they remain relevant to the needs of pupils and the wider IT industry.
To be known by the acronym UKForCE, it says its aim is to “bring together representatives from across the communities of education, computer science, digital media, IT, engineering and telecommunications”. 
The press information announcing the venture also said that UKForCE “will be independent of government and awarding organisations and will work towards improving computing education across all education sectors of the UK”.
Chair of the new organisation, Chris Mairs, who is also the chief scientist at Metaswitch Networks, added: “The new computing curriculum, which comes into effect in September 2014, is a most welcome step-change in computingeducation.
“There are many amazing initiatives springing up to build upon this bold move, both inside and outside the classroom.
“UKForCE will be the connective tissue between all these initiatives, central government and other relevant bodies. With a coherent voice and government commitment, our children will be the world’s most savvy digital citizens and a tremendous asset to the UK economy.
“As well as providing a springboard for great software engineers andcomputing specialists, effective delivery of the new curriculum can literally improve the life chances of an entire generation. UKForCE will help make this happen.”

Support in place?

The support mechanisms seem to be in place so teachers can begin to plan for the new computing curriculum, but many teachers will still need a lot of help and encouragement and it will be a few years before the impact of the new curriculum can be evaluated.
Key questions include: what will the critical success factors be and how will we know whether the change has been successful?
This is such an enormous change to the curriculum and there are some who are concerned about the balance between the three key elements mentioned earlier and the perceived over-emphasis on computer science. 
Hopefully this will be the top item on the agenda of the new UK Forum forComputing Education at its first meeting in 2014. As for the use of technologyacross the curriculum, well that is another story altogether! 
  • Bob Harrison is a school and college governor, chair of the teacher-led computing expert group and the Teaching Schoolstechnology advisory board. He is also education advisor for Toshiba Information Systems and writes for SecEd in a personal capacity. You can follow him on Twitter @bobharrisonset.

Further information
Technology-enhanced learning

Friday, 17 January 2014

The "Teaching MOT" - the ticket to a smooth running profession or just another way to be fleeced?

 
Picture
So the latest furore which has erupted in the world of teaching is a suggestion by the Shadow Education Secretary, Tristram Hunt, that teachers should be licensed in order to stay in the profession, and that a Royal College of Teaching be set up. In an interview with the BBC Hunt noted that teacher should have "the same professional standing" as lawyers and doctors, "which means re-licensing themselves, which means continued professional development, which means being the best possible they can be," (Of course, if Hunt is serious about giving teaching "the same professional standing" as law and medicine, he might want to consider the pay and conditions of teaching as well as the licensing aspect!). He went on to say that "if you're not willing to engage in re-licensing to update your skills then you really shouldn't be in the classroom,"

Twitter seems to have exploded with anger at the proposals:

@sharpeleven: I think @TristramHuntMP may have lost #Labour hundreds of thousands of votes with his idiotic bash-teachers grandstanding. #NoToLabour

@NewcastleNUT: Well done @TristramHuntMP 3months in post you finally find something to say and alienate the whole teaching profession at once @TeacherROAR

@senornunes: Tristram Hunt in danger of becoming more unpopular than Gove. Incredible. Teachers expect Labour to respect them and education @TeacherROAR

@itvnews: Furious teachers react to licence MOT proposal http://t.co/3NKJpLUwfK
These are just a few of the thousands of responses I ended up browsing this morning. But what exactly are people getting so worked up about? Why is this proposal arousing such anger? Surely we want well respected teachers who have been recognised as being professionally excellent? I think the answer to this lies more in the morale of the teaching profession than anything else.

The big issue we have as a profession at the moment is anger. Tory education "policy" has been so fast paced and erratic that teachers have been placed very much on the back foot. We find ourselves constantly under attack - we are on the defensive and want to hit back. We demand an end to Gove's meddling. We want Ofsted to be abolished. We want a system which is supportive and doesn't encourage schools to battle with one another. All of these issues are core to the development of the teaching profession, we care deeply about them, and rightly so. But in among all the anger and frustration, there is also an element of hysteria. Every announcement made in education is greeted with a similar level of vitriol (though often by different groups of people with their own sectional interests). To many on the outside, the profession seems to be just raging against the machine. This is a dangerous position to be in. Now I am not arguing that a huge proportion of the changes which have been brought in don't deserve such a response, however, I am also concerned that the reaction of the profession means we sometimes miss the positive opportunities when they arrive.

The removal of National Curriculum levels is one example of a potentially liberating move which has been lost under a blanket of other measures and therefore is going unnoticed. Too many schools seem to want to continue with the old Levels system and not innovate, despite the fact that this is the greatest degree of freedom the KS3 curriculum has been given since 1991. We seem to have lost faith in the political system to such an extent that almost any proposal is treated with suspicion. Hunt's licensing idea does have drawbacks, and yes it may well be abused, but if properly implemented it could well be a positive move for the profession - especially if teachers are brought into its creation from the outset. The devil, as Christine Blower rightly says, will be in the detail. So why should we give this a chance? Why might this actually be a good thing for teaching?
Picture
Firstly, Michael Gove seems intent on removing any kind of qualification bar from the profession - the destruction of university-based teacher training being just one example of this. This is connected to another key issue, namely a worrying strand of anti-intellectualism which runs through parts of the profession (most commonly I have found it to be evident in a previous school in the attitudes of over-promoted SLT members; but it is also ingrained in a lot of Gove's proposals which liken teaching to a kind of babysitting). Yet how many of us have tuned in to watch the "bright young things" on "Tough Young Teachers" flounder and fail in the classroom. "They've got all the qualifications" we say "but it doesn't make them good teachers." To an extent, this is perfectly true, no amount of degrees makes you a good teacher. Good teaching and relating to kids taps into other areas and abilities. However you can be damn sure that if some of these "tough young teachers" survive, then they will be able to offer a huge amount to their students. Tom Bennett put it nicely in his review of the show when he said "...they were doing what every teacher does first day on the job: making mistakes, so that they didn't make them again, or at least made them again, but less."

I got into quite a heated debate recently when someone ridiculed a man who held two masters' level degrees for having only survived a few days of teaching. The person in question noted with glee how his mother had come in to pick up his things. What had he done to deserve this? He tried hard in school, worked through the education system and then wanted to give something back. Sometimes we seem to revel in the failure of the highly qualified more than others for some reason. Sadly this experience is not isolated. I can distinctly remember, 2 years ago, being told not to bother interviewing a history candidate with a PhD as he would be "no good at relating to kids." Now, as it turned out, he was not the best candidate for the job, but that was nothing to do with his qualifications. We have to stop attacking our own. Teaching needs a mix of people - it should never be dominated by a single group so why do we give those with high academic qualifications such a hard time? To some extent, embedding CPD into teacher licensing may level the playing field here too. It allows teachers to be respected for their experience, but also for the fact they have continued to develop their understanding of the profession.

I think Hunt is right when he says that in order for the teaching profession to be of the best quality, it needs to have its own standards body. With the demise of the QTS standard, a Royal College might be a suitable protection of professional freedom. Of course we had such a body previously with the creation in 1998 of the ill-fated GTC. But this has the potential to be different. For starters, the GTC was treated with suspicion by teachers from the outset, reducing its potential impact from the beginning. Yet when QTS was abolished along with the GTC, many teachers saw this as a loss. If teachers can be part of the RCT from the start then it may well become a trusted body by government and teachers alike.

Picture
Secondly, licensing may well be a means to give teachers an entitlement to real professional development. By this, I don't mean those horrific courses where we are all told to do more group work, or use Bloom's Taxonomy (I had to attend dozens of those in a previous school), I mean access to real, subject specific development courses and materials. Moreover it should mean that we can have a professional development system designed by teachers and for teachers, rather than one borrowed from business. I have never understood why my "appraisal" runs on the same lines as those for a telesales firm, but it does! Even in the highly competitive world of banking, appraisal processes are nowhere near as demoralising as in teaching. The appraisal system has never suited teaching because it is not designed for professionals who need to be focusing on their professional knowledge and practice more than "results."

If Mr Hunt wants to create a well-respected teaching profession, then teachers need to broaden their knowledge of what and how they actually teach. The latter in particular needs to be rooted in evidence.
If teachers are then recognised for this in a positive way we might be getting somewhere. Of course, this is highly personal and changes with time. When I began teaching I asked for a lot of my CPD to be around issues of classroom management; even today I like to have a good read of Tom Bennett's behaviour blogs just as a refresher. These days, my main focus is on improving my understanding of the historical subjects I teach. Whatever system Hunt wants, it has to recognise that teachers are able to take charge of their CPD. Over the years I have been fortunate enough to have access to some excellent subject CPD - I WANT to be judged on these - I WANT people to know I do them. Some of the items below give an idea of the kind of CPD I have found useful over the years.
  • Lectures and sessions on various historical periods and events - usually attended in my own time, though occasionally sanctioned. These have given me some excellent ideas for teaching and have add depth and character to so many lessons.
  • Schools History Project and Historical Association sessions looking at specific aspects of teaching history in the classroom
  • Discussion and dialogue with colleagues
  • Reading - I cannot stress how much my own practice improves when I get the chance to read about the subjects I teach, even those that I have taught for a long time. Reading gives me the stories of human interest, the debates, the discussion - frankly it keeps the subject alive. Equally I read articles on pedagogy in teaching journals when I get the time.

The above point of course also means that there must be a concerted effort to stamp out these pseudo-CPD courses which latch onto the latest teaching fad. To name a few disasters I have attended in previous schools:
  • iPads for learning - a course on how making videos and finger paintings on iPads improves kids' understanding of history. "How?" I hear you ask... well because it makes history fun and accessible...and Wikipedia has all the answers anyway!?!
  • Learning styles - a bastardisation of Howard Gardner's multiple intelligences. I have been "taught" on a number of occasions how roleplays are the solution to learning as well as top tips to get all "learners" engaged through "VAK" techniques...
  • Questioning Strategies - Another "Bloom" based CPD session where we were told that asking "higher order questions" was the key to quality learning and subject knowledge was irrelevant.
  • Any number of "teacher led" CPD courses where the person taking the session clearly has never investigated the area on which they are supposed to be expert. I won't bore you with the details here, but a previous school moved to a CPD programme run exclusively by staff in-house. It was a disaster but the school made a lot of money farming the courses out to the LA.
  • AFL - Ah... AFL... or as I like to call it, "teaching properly"
  • Opening Minds - enough said
  • Middle Leaders Development Programme - The mother of all crap courses - so bad that even the NCSL abandoned it as "not rigorous enough". Essentially a course where current "leaders" tell would-be "leaders" how to bully staff to "improve results." All of this coupled with a project to "improve results" which nobody checks and nobody actually cares about.

The list goes on! The simple fact is that few schools give teachers access to good quality CPD in terms of resources or, just as importantly, time. Just look at the issues around the teaching of WWI at the moment. In order to really access that debate, history teachers need to be reading the most recent scholarly arguments in the historiography of the topic. We teach such a broad range of historical areas that it is sometimes hard to keep on top of this. If this proposal meant that we were given time and money to develop our subject knowledge, then this must surely be a good thing. I would love the chance to go and read about the Georgian period (sadly neglected in the current curriculum) and bring this into my 2014 curriculum. I desperately want to help other people love my own subjects of expertise (the Middle Ages and American West bizarrely enough), but unless people have a chance to read great history about it, it is hard to get them enthused. It is surely a prerequisite of a good history department that teachers are given the time to read about their subject? In this way we might see some really interesting new topics appearing alongside the old Medieval Realms to 20th Century World courses.

Picture
Finally, a system of licensing might well relieve the pressure on the vast majority of teachers who do care deeply about their profession, and whose efforts are often denigrated or go unseen. At the moment, Ofsted operate a system of "class detentions" - everyone gets punished when things go wrong in a school. If there are problems, these need to be targeted and dealt with in proportion. The talk of failing teachers must not dominate the discussion. But however we look at this, there are still a small core of teachers out there who feel that developing their understanding of what they teach is not necessary - I know because I have worked with and for them. There are not many of them, but they exist. Similarly there are teachers who believe that a CPD session on teaching kids with plasticine, or doing yet another session on AFL, constitutes professional development. We have to accept at least part of the charge that some teachers are not doing what is needed for kids to get a good education, even when they are doing the job for all the right reasons.

Teaching, especially in a subject like history puts a high demand on professional knowledge, which in turn demands engaging with real CPD. A licensing system, if enacted properly would act as a seal of approval on those teachers, the vast, vast majority, who are always engaged in improving their knowledge and pedagogical understanding. Of course, this also means the rhetoric has to change from government - this policy must be discussed in the same way that professional development in law and medicine is discussed, as positive proof of a high quality profession, rather than as a means to root out under performance.

There will always be the worry that a qualification might be a stick to beat teachers with. In previous schools, I have seen teachers pushed out of the profession by narrow minded managers who wouldn't know high quality teaching if it hit them with a stick. We have to protect good teachers from this kind of pressure. But I honestly believe, if properly controlled and regulated, a "teaching MOT" might also be a passport to independence. Again, in previous schools, I have had to bite my tongue when yet another ill-conceived initiative was made into one of my Professional Development targets (integrating iPads into the history classroom springs to mind, or indeed completing the NCSL Middle Leadership qualification). And I have seen staff attacked for not teaching in a specific way. A system of teacher controlled, independently accredited CPD, would allow teachers to break away from the narrow interests of a particular leader or manager and focus on high quality CPD. They key is having some control over what constitutes good professional development, and that is exactly why we need to be part of building this from the ground up. For too long CPD has been in the thrall of educational fads and people out to make a quick buck. It has to stop - a Royal College could be part of the solution.

A Labour government will have their work cut out to implement a system such as this - however, if they were able to make it work it has the potential to change teaching for the better. We desperately need to break out of the business model of professional development and the Ofsted model of assessing teacher quality. We need to be united as a group of professionals. If there is a system which might take us in that direction, then we need to grab onto it and help mold it into the kind of system we want to see.

Wednesday, 8 January 2014

Brain scientists to work with schools on how to learn



Cross section of a human headThere are calls for more evidence about academic study and the functioning of the brain

Related Stories

A £6m fund has been launched to make better use of neuroscience in classrooms in England.
The scheme, backed by the Wellcome Trust and Education Endowment Foundation, wants more evidence-based research into how schoolchildren's brains process information.
This could include how the brain's performance is damaged by sleep loss.
The Wellcome Trust's Hilary Leevers says there has been an "evidence gap" in applying neuroscience in schools.
The Education and Neuroscience project wants to fund research that will bring together scientists and educators.
It also wants to replace "myths" about how the brain functions with an understanding based on research.
Brain power
Introducing the project at the Education Media Centre, Dr Leevers suggested that while there had been many advances in analysing how the brain worked, they had made little impact on classroom practice.
Where there were computer-based "brain training" exercises being used in schools, she said there was not much reliable evidence to show whether they really brought benefits.

“Start Quote

Knowing the impact of neuroscience in the classroom will also make it easier to spot the plausible sounding fakes and fads, which don't improve standards”
Sir Peter LamplEducation Endowment Foundation
Kevan Collins, chief executive of the Education Endowment Foundation, said that schools needed to make better use of the research available - and warned that at present its application for classroom use was "often haphazard and not well informed".
There was a need for evidence-based research that was "politician proof", he said.
Mr Collins said that there were many ideas that "catch on" in schools, with the aim of aiding learning - such as playing music to pupils or making them drink lots of water - but not much clear evidence of what worked.
There was also the risk of doing more harm than good, he warned. He gave the example of the unanswered question of whether extra lessons on Saturday mornings brought benefits or whether they damaged pupils' motivation.
Mr Collins said that the school system should know whether "increasing the dosage" would help or hinder pupils - and this required reliable research.
Lack of sleep
Paul Howard-Jones from the University of Bristol said there may be practical benefits from applying neuroscience research more effectively.
As an example, he said that maths lessons could be improved if teachers had a better understanding of what stimulated the brain.
Neuroscience could also influence the school timetable, he says, if there was evidence that starting later in the day would help teenagers to learn.
The impact of lack of sleep on the functioning of the brain should be considered in the length of the school day and lessons, he said.
Parents also face adverts for computer-based exercises which claim to improve children's learning.
But Dr Howard-Jones said there was no convincing evidence to show whether or not such computer applications could boost academic achievement.
Mr Collins said he was "convinced of the need to do more" to develop and evaluate the use of neuroscience in education.
Sir Peter Lampl, who chairs the Education Endowment Foundation and the Sutton Trust, said: "Knowing the impact of neuroscience in the classroom will also make it easier to spot the plausible sounding fakes and fads, which don't improve standards."

Treasure hunting for knowledge

image
Soundtrack for this post:
http://youtu.be/ta-Z_psXODw
ARRRRGGGHHHH! Pirates are cool. Treasure hunts are cool. Allowing your learners the freedom to go hunting for knowledge is definitely cool. For the last few years I have set up various types of treasure hunt, which have had different levels of success. These include *huge* amounts of preparation work and you have to trust your class to actually do the treasure hunt as opposed to bunking off to the canteen. I like the freedom it gives my learners and it builds a really positive relationship with the teacher if you make your expectations clear. I have also found treasure hunts of any kind bring out the competitive side of my learners, so be prepared to see them really hyped up. Mind you – a little bit of enthusiastic anarchy for one lesson never hurt anyone, and it did wonders for drawing in the slightly disaffected members of the class. I am going to write about three types of treasure hunt I have tried: a traditional Harry Potter inspired one, geocaching and a QR code hunt.
Harry Potter Treasure Hunt
This one was based in a circuit of check points around the inside of the college building. Groups were given different start points so that they all progressed around the circuit, they should in theory, not bump into each other or clog parts of the college. Each check point had an activity to complete before they could follow the clue to the next check point. The clues were written on scrolls and were totally naff and rhyming. For example- ‘If it is the next check point you seek, think about where you wipe your feet.’ Well, ok, maybe not quite that naff, but you get the idea. I called it a Harry Potter hunt, but really it wasn’t – it was just scrolls, but I think that sounded better than a Rachel treasure hunt! The learners all raced off with zeal. The clues seemed to work and I was pleased as they rushed about solving the puzzles. The problem came when the next class came to do the same activity. Some ne’er-do-wells had moved the clues! Disaster. Whole class wondering around, unable to finish the task without my intervention. It’s ok to make mistakes, and I had not really planned for the clues going AWOL. In the end I had to take the students back to the classroom and fill in the piece of the task they had missed. However, the activity was still valid. They were engaged and really proactive in the pursuit of knowledge and the activities at the check points extended their learning. I learnt that I needed to have a back up plan, which is a valuable lesson if you are willing to take risks in your teaching.
Geocaching
image
Not just the preserve of geographers! Geocaching is an outside activity that uses GPS devices or apps to find a cache, or small treasure. It is great fun and there are probably hundreds only a short distance from where you are sat right now. Have a look here to see geocaching.com I asked my students to download a GPS app, and then follow a circuit trail around the grounds of college, which I had set up with help from a geocaching enthusiast. A cache is a disguised box, and I put a learning activity in each one as well as the GPS position of the next cache. The caches themselves can be quite cunningly disguised, some are camouflaged, some have magnets on so you can really go to town hiding them on the side of pipes, in holes in the wall and in bushes. It’s fair to say my AS class were *very* excited to try this, even though it was freezing cold outside. On the whole they all followed the circuit well with only minimal cheating on the harder caches. We had some problems with phones where I didn’t consider the apps as useful as they could have been- but in teams they did all acquire the knowledge required for that lesson. I wouldn’t use this type of activity to teach a key bit in the course, but for blowing off steam after a serious topic, or after exams it was brilliant. Again, it emphasises the trust you have in your learners, and it got them running about outside, which is always nice to see in older learners. Extending your classroom to the outside can be a valuable activity if you plan effectively to ensure that they are on task, and it engages them more fully with the subject and the importance of them taking control of their own learning rather than being focused on the teacher.
QR code treasure hunts
I designed a series of lessons that utilised Solo Taxonomy as well as indulging my geekier side with student generated QR codes, where they created and then undertook treasure hunts using their mobile phones. This was designed to self/peer teach Feminist approaches to Inequality and replaced lesson plans that last year featured a 34 slide PowerPoint (the horror!).
Lesson One- Students were divided into small groups of two or three and given an area of Feminist enquiry into inequality to become expert in, for example Hakim, the Pensions gap, and so on. They had an hour and a half to research the topic and then create a Solo style station with QR codes that would enable other students to research and become experts in that area. The classroom was soon filled with learners utilising their own devices to research and then create resources for the use of other groups. By the end of the lesson all the groups had produced QR codes that linked to relevant web based or student student generated content. They had achieved the unistructural phase of learning. My students found this site good for generating the QR codes: http://qrcode.kaywa.com/
image
image
Lesson Two-The students arrived with a QR scanner already downloaded onto their devices. They then worked round the room using the QR stations to complete a grid that covered the content of the specification. I was amazed at the quality of the content that the QR codes led too. Students had not only linked them to web content, but had also created podcasts, infographics, and even a twitter account (for a dead Marxist Feminist) to assist their classmates in their learning. The beep noises the phones make when they scan the codes made my classroom sound like Tesco checkout, but the students were totally engrossed working round the various stations to ensure that they completed the grid. I found that there was a surprising amount of peer support and sharing of information. All students completed the grid, which was a demanding amount of material. This was the multi-structural phase of their learning.
Lesson Three- This was the day the sun first came out and so we decided to decamp to outside. Before doing this each group was given a giant hexagon and told to summarise their initial uni-structural learning onto it. We then took the hexagons outside and spent time as a whole class moving the hexagons around to create evaluative links between the theorists. This was more complicated than it sounds and took some negotiation between the different opinions and evaluations of individual learners. This negotiation, and the evaluative skills that it required to reach a collaborative conclusion, was the relational and extended abstract phase of the learning as it promoted the learners to think beyond the information presented and utilise learning from other modules and even areas outside the formal learning of the course.
image
This type of treasure hunt is really successful if all your learners have access to the technology to create and undertake it. You can run into problems if they are sharing phones or devices, so you need to ensure that you plan effectively around this issue. However, the effectiveness of the treasure hunt was that the students made the QR codes themselves and were therefore invested into the importance of the quality of their output, as they knew other learners would need their information to complete the task. If you are interested to find out more about using QR codes try here:http://ictevangelist.com/how-to-make-use-of-qr-codes-with-your-ipad-teachers-students/
So- three types of treasure hunt where some were more successful that others. However, across the board students on leaving college tend to recall these lessons as ones they enjoyed. I know this is in part due to the structured chaos that letting them loose can bring. However, if you plan well then the impact on their learning can be massive as it encourages a positive mindset amongst them that the teacher doesn’t have to be the focus of the lesson and that they are trusted to take ownership of their own learning. What do you think?

Monday, 6 January 2014

Teachers and Learners in an Electronic World: A Review of the Literature

link to paper

TLT13 book



On Saturday 19th October, #TLT13 was held at the University of Southampton Education School.  The day was focused around sharing and collaborating professional ideas around various core elements of teaching and learning.  The day involved a number of workshops, presentations and Teachmeet Style sessions.  To celebrate the fantastic day, we have put together a #TLT13 book that aims to share many of the ideas and resources that were discussed.  The book is separated into the various workshop categories and include resources from all of the workshop leaders.
the book pdf version

10 Specific Ideas To Gamify Your Classroom

10 Specific Ideas To Gamify Your Classroom

, 
how-to-gamify-your-classroom10 Specific Ideas To Gamify Your Classroom
by Mike Acedo
In today’s classroom, educators are constantly required to mold their teaching methods to give students the best opportunity to succeed. It is not only imperative for students to learn the required material, but also critical that students gain a sense of confidence toward their work, and find motivation to expand their learning.
However, this can be difficult for some students, who may struggle in traditional, lecture-based class styles. For some students, finding the motivation to complete homework or prepare for class can be a constant struggle, especially when every effort is met with a poor grade or frustration from teachers and parents. Therefore, teachers must become more and more creative when motivating students to learn.
We’ve talked about designing your classroom like a video game before. Games are one motivator that almost all kids are responsive to. Many teachers have had the experience of asking students to stop playing games such as Angry Birds during class. However, it can be rationalized that games can be a very strong motivator for students when the same game elements are applied in an educational context. Thus, some educators have adopted the concept of Gamification, where the structure of gaming is applied to a non-game framework.
Though some teachers may use game-based learning, such as having students play games like Minecraft or Civilization to reinforce content, Gamification uses game elements such as challenges, feedback, levels, creativity, and rewards to motivate students to learn, and master concepts.
How To Gamify Your Classroom: 10 Specific Ideas To Get It Done
1. Make Students Co-Designers
Present the class syllabus as a form of Gamification. Work together with students to develop the narrative of the class, as well as short, and long-term goals. Allow students to have a voice in the class design, vote on a model that agrees with everyone, work with it, learn from it, and revise it as the class goes on. As a result, students will be put behind the wheel of their own learning, allowing them to express creativity and some control over the direction of the class.
Given that the class design is a collaborative effort, it will give students a sense of ownership toward the outcome of the class, and in turn, motivate them to participate and succeed within the class narrative. Additionally, since the class and assignment design is done in a collaborative process, students who would otherwise struggle in a traditional class setting, will have the opportunity to be involved in creating a learning space they can excel in.
2. Allow Second Chances. And Third.
Like in video games, students should be allowed second chances. When a challenge is failed in a video game, users are able to learn from their mistakes, try again, and succeed. The same concept can be applied to the classroom, as students should be able to try an assignment, either succeed or fail, and try again. Students who succeed right away have the choice to either move on to a new challenge, or try to raise their score.
At the same time, students who failed the first time, have the opportunity to learn from their mistakes, and try again until they succeed. This motivates students to learn for themselves in order master skills and raise achievement, while eliminating the pressure or stigma of failure. In games, and in life, failure is an essential component of success. Students should be allowed to fail and learn from their mistakes without feeling dejected or unmotivated to try again. Though this will require more work in terms of grading for teachers, student performance and understanding will undoubtedly rise.
3. Provide Instant Feedback
This one isn’t always easy, so you may need to use your noodle a bit.
In a game setting, feedback is essential for users to know how they are doing in the game. If a user makes a choice in a game, it is usually known immediately if that choice was the right one. Classrooms must work in a similar fashion, as students must be able to receive and give feedback so it is known if the steps they are taking are in the right direction. Though computers provide immediate feedback in video games, it may take a teacher a little longer to provide feedback to individual students.
Therefore, it is essential that students are able to give feedback to each other, with the instructor providing support to those who need it. Teachers can split the class up in groups or learning “teams”, each with their own names and characteristics the students can customize within the classroom narrative. Students can then have the freedom to work together on assignments, provide feedback, and receive support from the instructor as needed.
4. Make Progress Visible
In games, users usually have levels or progress bars that indicate how well they are doing in the game. Gamified classrooms can implement similar elements which indicate how far along students are, and how close they are to reaching the next level. Instead of issuing grades or percentages, teachers can either issue progress bars to students, or allow them manage their own. With each completed assignment, test, or project, a certain amount of points can be added to their progress bar, bringing them closer to reaching the next level.
As high school teacher Alice Keeler explains in her gamified classroom, progress bars and levels allow students to set goals for themselves and celebrate success once achieving them. It also gives struggling students a tangible indication of how close they are to reaching the next level, allowing them to discern what they could have done better to get there. This can be tremendous for student confidence, as they are once again allowed to learn from their mistakes, and are motivated to raise their achievement to reach the next level.
5. Create Challenges Or Quests Instead Of Homework & Projects
In games, users are constantly required to meet challenges, such as identify patterns, break codes, or complete quests in order to advance. The same elements can be applied to a gamified classroom, as homework and projects can be presented in a fun, yet challenging way. By simply changing the context in which the assignments are presented, teachers transform the act of work into a more enjoyable, epic activity. Instead of assigning math homework, present it as a code that must be cracked in order to open a safe full of treats. Projects can also be presented in the similarly epic context, drawing students in to work and learn in a new way.
videogames-in-learning6. Give Students Voice & Choice
In many games, users are often given various choices that affect their progress, and the outcome of the game. Some are rewarded with extra lives or other benefits when completing harder challenges. The same choices can be implemented into gamified classrooms, allowing students different options they can use to reach their academic goals. As Alice Keeler explains in her classroom, students are given the choice to choose different paths in learning the curriculum.
For example, instead of simply issuing a test at the end of a subject, teachers can allow students to take different paths to demonstrate their understanding of the material.  Some students may choose to develop a group project and presentation, others may write an essay, make a board game, or express their understanding in other creative ways. By giving students choice, it allows them to foster and apply their knowledge in new, creative ways. Additionally, it gives them a sense of pride and ownership toward their work, which in turn fosters additional creativity and achievement
7. Offer Individual Badges & Rewards
Badges or other rewards are a good ways of recognizing student achievement and incentivizing students to continue raising their efforts in reaching academic goals. By providing a tangible symbol of achievement, badges and rewards can be very effective in celebrating certain student accomplishments, and can be a great tool for raising student confidence. Even if badges are given for simply attempting an assignment, completing extra credit, or showing continued effort in reaching a goal, the mere recognition of effort can go a long way in motivating students to learn.
8. Have Students Design A Class-Wide Skills & Achievement System
With your input of course.
To encourage an entire class to continually strive to raise their academic achievement, teachers must implement more than just individual badges and rewards as incentives. Teachers can implement a class-wide reward system, where everyone can celebrate individual and collaborative accomplishments. An example can be when a student reaches a new level or point total, certain skills or power-ups can be rewarded, such as the ability to choose a class-wide activity or game to play.
If an individual or group of students reach a certain level or point total, everyone in the class gets a moderate point boost as well. This class-wide reward system not only celebrates individual achievements, but also encourages each classmate to help each other so they may all be rewarded in some way. This promotes a sense of comrade and collaboration between students, as they find themselves sailing the same ship, which requires their combined effort to reach their destination.
9. Implement Educational Technology
Though gamification does not strictly require the implementation of technology to be successful, the 21st century student is already very accustomed to using technology in their everyday lives. Therefore, teachers have found creative ways to use technology to help enhance their gamified classes. Customizable classroom management systems such as ClassRealm have helped teachers easily manage their gamified classrooms, allowing teachers, students, and parents to track student achievements, encourage student participation through educational adventures and games, and set up academic goals for individual students.
Additionally, it rewards points to students for arriving to class on time, for completing assignments, reading extra books for class, and helping fellow students. This encourages students to advance their learning beyond required boundaries, while also motivating participation and peer assistance. Educational game designerGamestar Mechanic, and class behavior management system Class Dojo, are other popular tools that help teachers enhance student participation and achievement through gamification.
10. Embrace Failure; Emphasize Practice
An effective gamified classroom should not merely focus on the information being taught, but on the skills achieved, and the knowledge gained. The emphasis of gamification is to provide students with a fluid environment of self-directed learning. In this capacity, students will learn meaningful skills such as critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and an understanding of how to apply those skills. These are invaluable abilities that students will not only use in school, but throughout their own personal and professional lives.
Therefore, it is vital that teachers who use gamification in their classroom allow their students to try, fail, and learn, while simultaneously supporting their innate creativity and enhancing the curriculum. As previously described, by allowing students some choice and flexibility of assignments, teachers can observe what methods are working, which skills are being exercised and mastered, and can make adjustments or suggestions as student’s progress through the class.
Conclusion
Though there are those who criticize gamification, it is undeniable that gamification provides students and teachers with a new and innovative way of facilitating learning. Gamification has the ability to transform the classroom to teach students practical skills, foster collaboration and creativity, as well as motivate students to advance their own learning through self-guided instruction.
How To Gamify Your Classroom: 10 Specific Ideas To Get It Done