Thursday, 21 November 2013

The importance of qualified teachers


Date: 21st November 2013
Author: Dr Joanna Goodman
Theme: 
Education Policy, Leadership, NQTs, Teacher
Tags: Editorial, QTS

Even the government is divided over whether unqualified individuals should be allowed to teach in state-funded schools. Dr Joanna Goodman considers the debate. 

Debating the issue of the necessity for teaching qualifications for individuals employed by schools as teachers, the government views are divided, with Mr Gove advocating that academies and free schools may draw on the subject knowledge and passion of people without formal teaching qualifications, while Mr Clegg is of the opinion that schools should employ only qualified teachers to ensure “basic quality standard”.
Educationalists believe that standards are threatened by the absence of a national policy for trained and qualified teachers and trainers.
However, Mr Gove’s department disagrees, stating that state maintained schools should be able to “hire brilliant teachers who have not got qualifiedteacher status – and have the same advantage that private schools have to bring in great linguists, computer scientists, engineers and other specialists to inspire their pupils”.
Dr Seldon, head of Wellington College, compares teaching to parenting, where qualifications are not needed, and believes that Mr Clegg and others, who argue for teachers to be qualified, are misguided regarding the teacher’s role who, he says, is “much more akin to that of a parent (...) yet no one is suggesting parents go off for a university course to qualify as a parent”.
Although in his recent speech he made reference to teaching as a profession (strange analogy to parenting here) and acknowledged it as a reflective practice highlighting passion, intellect, love of subject and children as required qualities, his focus on teaching also fails to recognise that the aim of teaching is to enable learning, hence, I assume no references to pedagogy or necessity for teacher training.
Arguably, subject expertise and passion are teachers’ great qualities, however, for effective, by which I mean active, self-regulated and autonomous learning to occur, the focus of this debate needs to shift from the teacher to the learner. In this whole debate on qualified/unqualified teachers, we seem to have lost sight of what teaching and learning are all about.
Learning is complex and, although some students can be naturally attuned to meta-cognition, this is not the case with the majority of learners who need to be taught how to engage actively with the learning material, where knowledge acquisition is right at the bottom of the learning taxonomy.  
Therefore “good teachers”, to be effective in class, need much more than subject expertise and intellect. Great teachers are able to facilitate learning through the use of formative strategies in class and know when to step back, to allow for pupils’ reasoning, application and self-discovered, independent learning to occur.
In order to have a better understanding of principles which encourage children to learn and why some children are more successful than others, extensive studies into the psychology of learning focused on motivation and, in particular, on the association between motivation and learning outcomes have come to the fore (Boekaerts, 2002; Dweck, 1986), and it is relevant, when discussing classroom learning, to explore some theoretical aspects of learning which scaffold classroom interaction.
Learning is one of those terms about which many assumptions are made, but around which there is a silence in terms of assertions because it is complex and specific to different learners, and no single strategy works for all (Schunk and Zimmerman, 1998).
According to Hirst and Peters (1989), “educating people is not done by instant fiat. It takes time, and a variety of different processes of learning and teaching are involved”. 
Drawing on a range of European studies, including her own research in the Netherlands over the last 20 years, Boekaerts (1995) concluded that motivation, an essential element of successful learning, conceptualized in her research as specific self-regulatory skill, was necessary for learners to experience success in educational outcomes.
Since learning is not just limited to knowledge acquisition, for effective learning to occur, learners need to be equipped with appropriate skills, which means they need to know how to learn in order to be fully successful.
These skills are developed through classroom interactions and classroom dialogue by trained professionals whose aim is not just to impart or introduce knowledge, or new material, but to ensure that learning at a deeper level takes place and progress is made by individual students.
To assert, that this can be done by any unqualified individual with subject expertise, or indeed to liken it to parenting, is, frankly, both insulting and ridiculous.
Although I agree that not all qualified teachers are excellent and some industry experts can make excellent teachers, the training, including NQTs’ induction process, provide common ground for development and reflection, giving teaching a professional framework. 
Likewise, references to independent schools having the opportunities to employ unqualified teachers are hardly appropriate. First, the vast majority of independent school teachers have qualified teacher status. I have been recruiting teachers to independent schools for many years and it has never been a consideration to recruit an unqualified teacher.
Second, even if the private sector has the ability to employ unqualified academic staff, independent schools, and not all of them are beacons of excellence, work under different conditions to maintained schools, and what may be appropriate in some independent schools, would not necessarily be appropriate in state-funded schools where about 93 per cent of pupils are being educated.
In my view, the debate should focus more on learning, rather than on teaching. It is more about developing pupils as independent, sustainable learners – skills which are key to future success in the digital age, where students need to be prepared for life-long learning and multiple career changes. 
To assert, that this job can be done by unqualified individuals, however charismatic and knowledgeable, is to deny students opportunities that they deserve.
Teacher effect on learning is huge, just look at Professor John Hattie’s work on effect sizes in his paper Influences on Student Learning (Hattie, 1999). See below for more.
Students have only one chance of every year in education and their learning should be guided by qualified teachers who are committed to life-long learning themselves.
  • Dr Joanna Goodman has a doctorate in education from King’s College London. She is an educationalist with curriculum expertise, assessment in particular, and leadershipdevelopment. She is an experienced senior school leader, a school inspector and director of Cromwell Consulting.


Professor John Hattie’s table of effect sizes
 
In his paper Influences on Student Learning, Prof Hattie, Professor of Education at Auckland University, New Zealand, says that “effect sizes” are the best way of answering the question of what has the greatest influence on student learning. The effect sizes in his table are averaged from 180,000 research studies and form a credible guide for what has the greatest influence on student achievement. An effect-size of 1.0 is typically associated with advancing learners’ achievement by one year, or improving the rate of learning by 50 per cent or a two-grade leap in GCSE. An effect size of 0.5 is equivalent to a one-grade leap at GCSE. The list below shows Influence–Effect Size–Source of Influence:
  • Feedback–1.13–Teacher 
  • Student’s prior cognitive ability–1.04–Student 
  • Instructional quality–1.00–Teacher 
  • Direct instruction–0.82–Teacher 
  • Acceleration–0.72–Student
  • Remediation/feedback–0.65–Teacher 
  • Student’s disposition to learn–0.61–Student 
  • Class environment–0.56–Teacher 
  • Challenge of Goals–0.52–Teacher 
  • Peer tutoring–0.50–Teacher 
  • Mastery learning–0.50–Teacher 
  • Homework–0.43–Teacher 
  • Teacher Style–0.42–Teacher 
  • Questioning–0.41–Teacher 
  • Peer effects–0.38–Peers 
  • Advance organisers–0.37–Teacher 
  • Simulation & games–0.34–Teacher 
  • Computer-assisted instruction–0.31–Teacher 
  • Testing–0.30–Teacher 
  • Instructional media–0.30–Teacher 
  • Affective attributes of students–0.24–Student 
  • Physical attributes of students–0.21-Student 
  • Programmed instruction–0.18–Teacher 
  • Audio-visual aids–0.16–Teacher 
  • Individualisation–0.14–Teacher 
  • Finances/money–0.12–School
  • Behavioural objectives–0.12–Teacher 
  • Team teaching–0.06–Teacher 
  • Physical attributes (eg class size)–0.05–School
 
Further information
References
  • Boekaerts, M. (1995). Motivation in Education. The British Psychological Society.
  • Boekaerts. M. (2002). Motivation to Learn. Educational Practices – 10.  InternationalAcademy of Education.  UNESCO booklet.
  • Dweck, C. (1986). Motivational process affecting learning. American Psychologist. 41(10): 1040-48.
  • Hirst, P. H. and Peters, R.S. (1989). The Logic of Education. London: Routledge.
  • Schunk, D. and Zimmerman, B.J. (1998). Self-Regulated Learning: From Teaching to Self-Reflective Practice. Guildford: Guildford Press.

Tips for project-based learning


Project-based learning has the potential to teach key skills and knowledge in a more engaging and real-world way. Earnie Kramer looks at the pros and cons and offers some advice.

General-Classroom22.gif
Built on the principle that students learn better when taught through real-world problem-solving, project-based learning is a classroom model that emphasises enquiry-based, hands-on lessons that are student-directed.
Project-based learning, or PBL, somewhat abandons the traditionalcurriculum in that students are not required to learn specific facts on specific days. Rather, students are presented with a project (often working in groups) and are tasked with using their knowledge and lessons to solve problems and complete that project.

Benefits of project-based learning

Project-based learning gives schools the ability to:
  • Increase application and retention of information.
  • Encourage critical-thinking skills.
  • Foster communication and collaboration.
  • Boost high-stakes test scores.
  • Increase student motivation and engagement.
  • Teach real-world problem-solving.
  • Improve academic achievement.
  • Positively affect students’ attitudes toward learning.
  • Prepare learners for higher education.
  • Integrate knowing and doing.
  • Allow students to be mobile by offering them opportunities to learn in places besides the classroom or at home.
  • Show students that learning can take place anywhere, anytime.
  • Help students to become lifelong learners by requiring them to apply the knowledge they have learned to everyday or real-life problems.
  • Teach students that it is not enough to know information, but rather being able to use the information they have in a meaningful and productive way.
  • Create a learning atmosphere in which teachers coach student thinking and guide student review, allowing deeper levels of understanding.
  • Engage students as participants in a problem situation.
  • Organise lectures around a given holistic problem, enabling student learning in relevant and connected ways

Challenges of project-based learning

Some of the barriers to overcome when implementing project-based learninginclude the following:
  • Training teachers on how to implement PBL in the classroom and maintaining teacher energy levels from project to project.
  • Designing projects that both inspire and instruct students on common core standards.
  • Rethinking the old pedagogy of separating subjects so that skills are learned and honed holistically.
  • Finding classroom time to enthusiastically implement project-based learning amid test preparation and common core standards goals. 
  • It requires more time and takes away study time from other subjects.
  • It can sometimes be difficult for teachers who already have a way of doing things.
  • Being fair in assessment.
  • Building suitable project-based learning facilities in schools.
  • It might be challenging to implement project-based learning in some subjects – for example, subjects such as mathematics which is primarily skills-based at basic level.

Top tips for project-based learning

Give students a realistic problem or project. This achieves student buy-in and gets them excited about their project. If they can imagine encountering the problem that you have presented, they will be more interested in solving the problem. 
Make group work structured. Group students in sets of three to four with diversified skill levels so that each student has a defined role. 
Give multi-faceted assessments. Schedule multiple opportunities for students to revise their work and receive feedback through benchmarks, peer-grading, etc, so that work is monitored at several points throughout the project. Create benchmarks that focus on different aspects of the project so that students’ different roles are all highlighted.  
Participate in a professional network to support your efforts. Project-based learning does not just encourage collaboration among students, teachers and administrators can benefit as well. Constructive projects can take time to outline and create. Use the work and progress of your peers by using their successful assignments in your classroom. 

What teachers have told us

Teacher Steve Webb is clear on the benefits of project-based learning: “Usingproject-based learning allows me to focus teaching on a couple of really important skills for students’ development, such as leadership skills, collaborating productively, critical-thinking, communicating powerfully and completing projects effectively. This allows students to develop the life-skills that they need to be successful when moving on to university or the workplace.”
Fellow teacher Emma Jacobs adds: “Although it can be a challenging process, my students engage in learning more than ever and it is all down to better collaboration in classroom using project-based learning.”

Tuesday, 19 November 2013

A set of top Computer Science Education blogs

Computing: The Science of Nearly Everything

Computer Science…Research, Education and Policy

A set of top Computer Science Education blogs

Further to my most-read blog post (from May 2012: A set of top Computer Science blogs, 80,000 hits and counting), here’s a follow-up: blogs on computer science education.
As before, instead of a list, it more closely resembles a set: the order is irrelevant and there are no duplicate elements; membership of this set of blogs satisfies all of the following conditions:
  1. they focus on computer science education (research, policy and practice);
  2. they are of consistently high quality;
  3. I regularly read them.
  • Computing Education Blog by Mark Guzdial (@guzdial)
    Mark is a professor in the School of Interactive Computing at Georgia Institute of Technology and a researcher in computing education. His blog is about how people come to understanding computing, and how to facilitate that understanding, cross-cutting research, policy, practice and wider societal issues. And while it is US-focused (as you would expect), it is an excellent venue for the discussion of key topics in computer science education.
  • Teach Computing by Alan O’Donohoe (@teknoteacher)
    Alan is a busy chap: as well as being principal teacher of Computing at Our Lady’s High School in Preston, he’s the founder of both Hack To The Future and Raspberry Jam, the global community of events for everyone to discover the wonders of the Raspberry Pi. His blog tracks his five-year computing journey: from improving classroom practice (listen to his Teach Computing podcasts), contributing back to the community as a CAS Master Teacher, to shaping the development of a new curriculum subject in England.
  • Miss Philbin’s Teaching and Learning Journal by Carrie Anne Philbin (@MissPhilbin)
    Carrie Anne is an award-winning secondary teacher at Robert Clack School in Essex and a passionate advocate for women in technology. She is the creator of Geek Gurl Diaries, a YouTube web series for teenagers who want to be makers and creators of technology (which recently won a Talk Talk Digital Hero Award) and vice-chair of the CAS initiative #include to address diversity issues in computing. Her blog also covers the gamut of classroom practice, the transition from ICT to computing, supporting the wider community, to shaping policy in England.
  • Academic Computing by Neil Brown (@twistedsq)
    Neil is a research associate in the Programming Languages and Systems Group at the University of Kent, working on the BlueJ and Greenfoot projects. He writes thought-provoking pieces on topics spanning computing (and more broadly, STEM) education, programming and socio-technical issues. He also has a second blog on learning and applying mathematics through computing: The Sinepost.
  • An Open Mind by Miles Berry (@mberry)
    Miles is a principal lecturer and the subject leader for Computing Education at the University of Roehampton. He sits on the boards of both CAS and Naace, with wide experience of curriculum development in the UK. His blog, a personal perspective on education, technology and culture, covers a range of interesting pieces on computer science and programming pedagogy, CPD and agile practice.
  • Computer Science Teacher by Alfred Thompson (@alfredtwo)
    Alfred is a high school computer science teacher in New Hampshire, having previously been the K-12 Computer Science Academic Relations Manager for Microsoft and a software developer for 18 years. He currently sits on the board of the Computer Science Teachers Association. His blog covers a wide range of topics, including computer science and programming pedagogy, curriculum development and US education policy.
  • Knowing and Doing: reflections of an academic and computer scientist by Eugene Wallingford(@wallingf)
    Eugene is an associate professor and head of the Department of Computer Science at the University of Northern Iowa. He has been blogging since 2004 on topics across computing, software development, higher education, learning and teaching, as well as managing and leading.
  • Raspberry Pi Blog by the Raspberry Pi Foundation (@Raspberry_Pi)
    These guys need no introduction, especially after the two millionth Raspberry Pi was sold in October! With the huge success and penetration of the Raspberry Pi over the past two years, the platform now exists for the Foundation to fulfil its wider educational objectives. A diverse blog, ranging from technical posts, peripherals and resources, to superb examples of innovative uses of the Raspberry Pi.
  • CSTA Blog by the Computer Science Teachers Association (@csteachersa)
    The Computer Science Teachers Association is a membership organisation (free to join), supported by the ACM, that promotes and supports the teaching of computer science and other computing disciplines in the US, providing opportunities for K–12 teachers and students to better understand the computing disciplines and to more successfully prepare themselves to teach and learn. Its blog covers a wide range of topics across computer science education, programming, curriculum design and education policy,
  • CAS Online by Computing At School (@CompAtSch)
    Computing At School is a membership organisation (also free to join), supported by the BCS, that promotes and supports the teaching of computer science in UK schools. Formed in 2008, it now has over 7000 members from across schools, colleges, universities, industry and government and is the subject association for computer science. Along with numerous high-quality articles in the quarterly CAS newsletter, Switched On, CAS Online provides the UK computer science education community with a wide range of forums, events, policy discussions, consultations and a veritable wealth of resources to support learning and teaching.
This set is most definitely incomplete — please post your computer science education blog recommendations in the comments below. You can also read some of my posts on computer science education.

Thursday, 24 October 2013

Guardian 6 creative ways to use questions in the classroom


Teachers share ideas for how questions can be effectively used to engage students and check they've absorbed information
class questions
Questioning in the classroom: Get students to question the questions you ask, says Chris Curtis. Photograph: Alamy

Harry Fletcher-Wood, head of History and CPD co-ordinator at Greenwich Free School: @HFletcherWood

Using hinge Questions: I would not have believed that a major improvement in my teaching last year would have involved employing multiple choice questions. As I learned, however, multiple-choice hinge questions are a sophisticated and invaluable assessment technique to swiftly check whether the class has understood a critical point before moving on.
Crucially, the teacher designs responses to ensure student answers unambiguously demonstrate their underlying reasoning.
As a history teacher, for example, I might wish to know whether students appreciate what I mean by 'significant.' If I asked, 'what is significance?', one of the responses I would offer would be 'achieving something which improves people's lives'. Students frequently perceive significance to be synonymous with greatness and therefore would not deem a tyrant significant.
By designing each choice to represent a different line of reasoning, it is possible to immediately identify misunderstandings and take corrective action. If a lot of students have fallen into this trap, I may offer a brief example, or if it's a handful of pupils, I might have individual conversations. The hinge question is a key tool in ensuring students have understood a topic before a lesson ends.

David Doherty, has worked in a variety of roles in middle and secondary schools over the last 17 years: @dockers_hoops

Be creative with your questioning: Teachers ask around 400 questions every day, which adds up to a staggering 70,000 a year. Most of these are low cognitive questions and it's important to consider how to make these questions more effective in developing pupils' learning.
One way is to add variety to you questioning strategies. For example, randomly select pupils – there are many apps to help with this – so the same pupils aren't always answering questions. This also helps keep the class focused, as they don't know who's going to be chosen next.
Another idea is to vary the type of question you ask. Closed questions are fine when you're testing recall, but open questions allow pupils to explore a range of possible answers. The use of the word 'might' in a question also achieves this, as it removes the idea that there's a definitive right answer.
Lastly, well planned questions allow you to stretch all abilities in the class, as you can target questions at pupils based on their level. It also allows you to involve more pupils by playing volleyball with answers as you pass the responses around the room to other pupils.

Chris Curtis, English teacher and literacy co-ordinator: @Xris32

Question the questions: If you have been a teenager or have shared a house with a teenager, there is one thing you know: they question everything. Yet, we never really build this into lessons. Rarely do we get students to ask the questions. More importantly, we never get students to question the questions. Teenagers love questioning parents. Why were you late? Why didn't you pick me up, dad?
Aim to have occasions where students question the questions. For example, the question 'why did Shakespeare write about Othello losing control?' could lead to the following questions: What is losing control? What is Shakespeare trying to say about losing control?
Don't ask questions at the end of giving information: Intelligent people ask questions continually, yet the structure of lessons often revolves around learning followed by questions. Read this and answer the questions. Try to get students to ask questions throughout the learning and not at the end, where valuable opportunities are missed. Students often blank out words they don't know when reading, when they should be asking a question.
Harry, David and Chris were all speakers at a recent edsessential Teaching and Learning Takeover.

Wednesday, 23 October 2013

Developing higher order thinking skills with your learners

Developing higher order thinking skills with your learners

image
Creativity thinking and evaluative skills are key to my students success. Without exam skills that demonstrate higher order thinking skills they cannot achieve a AB grade in the exam. I am an advocate for equipping my own learners with what they will need, not only for exam success but also for life after education- this means focusing on thinking skills and developing them not just for performance in exams, but also their progression as a learner in FE, and beyond.
With that in mind, I trailed a new idea this week where students made Question Cubes. These were made from a box net, and they were asked to generate 6 questions, one for each face of the box. Question led learning can be very powerful, and a good way of demonstrating pre-structural learning and thus progress in a lesson. The students engagement in their own learning is heightened when the lesson is led by questions generated by them rather than simply posed by a teacher. It allows them to demonstrate their understanding of key terms, as well as make links with learning from previous lessons.
image
The students were encouraged to write higher order thinking questions, so they were framing their work with ‘evaluate’ or ‘analyse’ so they when asking the questions they could write answers that did more than simply demonstrate knowledge or understanding. As a starter they wrote questions on each face of the cube. The questions were based on the learning from the previous lesson, and will be used next lesson as part of a student led plenary. I also thought that they could be used by placing the blocks on top of each other, as this would create a 3D questioning prompt, which learners could use in a meaningful way to inform essay writing or planning.
image
Another activity which I tried this week was creating evaluative bunting. During the previous lesson I had used SOLO taxonomy so that my learners had multi-structural knowledge on theorists on social deprivation and educational attainment. I wanted them to be able to apply this knowledge in an evaluative way, so I asked the class in groups to draw the theorists ideas on bunting- one theorist per flag, the focus of course was not on the art work and there were stickmen a plenty! They then swapped work with another group and tried to label the drawings with the correct theorists. I encouraged them to write in each other’s work, and to be comfortable with making mistakes- it was an excellent opportunity to promote some positive learner characteristics about celebrating effort and risk taking. They were then tasked with creating the physical bunting- an were asked to string in so that each flag had an evaluative relationship with the ones next to it. This was much enjoyed, and my classroom is now festooned with higher order bunting. In addition to that my learners are now comfortable talking about higher order thinking skills, and being creative in order to advance their academic skills.
image
image
To consolidate this activity the class used hexagons and drew on relational links which they flag also created. They did his individually but drew on the work done in groups. I should also mention that the class were also live tweeting their learning, which is have written about before and is an excellent tool if you have the confidence with the technology.
image
Improving our learners higher order thinking skills is really important. Not just for the exam but for their ability to be an effective learner in the long term. Making these evaluation part of a physical process has been successful for me- would be very interested to hear if you have tried anything similar. How else can we improve these skills?

Monday, 21 October 2013

Nudge theory in education

Nudge Theory and Education

Anthony Steed
I have recently finished reading an interesting book entitled Nudge: Improving decision about Health, Wealth and Happiness. Authors David Thaler and Cass Sunstein draw upon research in behavioural economics to make some interesting assertions about human psychology and behaviour. The central notion of the book is that human beings make poor choices and are often irrational in their behaviour; that is to say they do not always make the best judgements given the information available and that these judgements are often influenced detrimentally by their peers. Anybody who has spent about 10 minutes in a classroom or has children of their own will immediately be able to identify with this notion.
The authors argue that the correction of these behaviours require a series of subtle ‘nudges’ as a way of encouraging people to make certain choices. They argue that simply telling people what to do often fails to work because more often than not the person doing the telling is wrong. So what, if anything, can the book teach us about correcting this irrationality and how could this translate into practical education policy? Below are some ideas I had as to its applications in the classroom and across the school;
1. Replace detention with ‘freetentions’ – OK the name doesn’t really work but the principle is sound. People are loss averse. The idea here is that human beings respond better to incentives than punishments. Imagine a school where the standard day finishes at 3.30pm. All students currently finish at this time, with the exception of the naughty ones who are often kept behind. Those children who struggle with their behaviour are regularly kept behind, as a result they begin to assimilate this into their expectations – in their mind the day finishes at 4.30pm as they are used to being put into detention and this is a price they are willing to pay for their behaviour. The result is that the disincentive loses its impact. Now imagine the same school where the typical day finishes at 3.30pm, but any child whose behaviour is good will be allowed to leave at 3pm. Moreover, they could choose to save these ‘time bonuses’ up and cash them in for a full or half-day off. What impact do we think this might have on some students? Remember…people (and kids) are loss averse.
2. Parents Day – not a totally new idea as I’m aware some schools already do this effectively already. This strategy could be directed at groups of parents to enhance their role in their child’s education and improve relationships between teachers and parents. The idea here is that many parents still maintain a negative perception of their child’s school and teachers. This is often based on memories of their own educational experience which create negative bias. Nudge theory would contend that these opinions are incorrect for two reasons;  firstly, in most cases the child will be taught by a different teacher and at a different school than the parent was, and so any such comparisons are spurious; secondly, the parents memories are often inaccurate, with particular incidents remembered and other positive experiences forgotten. In other words the parents’ negative perceptions are based on incomplete information. A Parents Day, where parents go into school and have a day of lessons without their children may give the parents a more accurate picture of what a school experience is all about and close the information gap.
3. Allow kids to choose which lessons they attend – Controversial I know but please bear with me. Imagine a school gives students a free choice that goes something like this, “Today you can attend any lessons you want, but you must attend for the entire day and you can only attend each lesson once”. What do we think would happen? If we take boys for example, I would hazard a guess that PE, Computing and perhaps Music would be packed. I would also hazard a guess that English and Languages classes would be devoid of males. OK, so obviously we want a balanced curriculum but how can we ‘nudge’ them into doing a variety of subjects whilst maintaining the illusion of choice? What if we made it easier or more appealing for boys to attend English but did this in a subtle way? For instance, we could make English lessons 45 minutes as opposed to an hour and offer English at the end of the day (so they could get away earlier). Or we could put English lessons on in the most comfortable rooms? Or we could give boys a ‘bonus’ (to be determined) if they attend an English lesson? By giving kids a choice but offering different levels of incentives to ‘guide’ their behaviour we are engaging in what the authors called ‘choice architecture’ – maintaining the notion of free choice whilst subverting this free choice with incentives to achieve the best outcome.
4. Change an ‘opt in’ to an ‘opt out’ – rather than letting kids off the hook by asking them to ‘opt in’ to something change the default position to an ‘opt out’. This idea gets to the heart of human psychology and plays on our inbuilt desire to avoid confrontation and our ability to feel guilt. This could be applied effectively to a number of areas around the school – for example, as a means of encouraging students to partake in extra-curricular activities a letter could be sent to parents stating that an after school club is compulsory unless the parents choose for their child to opt out.
5. Improve information for school leavers (when they’re 11) – this is one idea that is currently being pursued on a national level. Research has shown that children from poor disadvantaged backgrounds often have poor knowledge of their further or higher education options and the careers they could lead them into. As a result such children often view professional qualifications and careers as unobtainable. By filling this information gap it may be possible to raise aspirations among the most disaffected. This idea could be taken even further by providing parents with this information as well.
6. Pay kids to go to school – some schools have already employed similar policy, somewhat controversially, as a way of improving student attendance. However, the policy could applied much more broadly and linked directly to students performance. The argument is simple – kids react to incentives (like all of us). The problem is that some children don’t feel or understand their incentives to go to school and work hard. A monetary incentive (or something similar) is an incentive they can easily understand. Although the policy may seem morally wrong actually, based purely on a cost benefit analysis  it may actually make financial sense. If we consider the enormous amount of resources devoted to improving student attainment, paying students to do well in school may actually save the treasury money in the long run
7. Use peer pressure – put up posters in your classroom showing statistics about homework completion or behaviour  i.e. “75% of the class completed their homework last week”. This policy again draws upon and exploits human guilt in a similar way to the ‘opt out’ idea. A similar policy was trialled with great success in Bedfordshire hospitals in 2011. Doctors began placing notices in their waiting rooms along the lines of “95% of patients kept their appointments this month”. The result was a marked improvement in the number kept appointments or prompt cancellations (although it should be acknowledged that this policy was one of a number)
8. Send personalised text message as reminders about deadlines – Again drawing upon a policy implemented by Bedfordshire hospitals as a way of reducing missed appointments. This time we are closing the information gap. I have trialled something similar myself, having set up an email group and emailing students prior to a submission date.
9. Share progress information – this is already being used to great success in some areas within my own school and doubtless in schools up and down the country. Set up a spreadsheet for all of the students in your class. Use a traffic light system – green for a good piece, yellow for an acceptable piece and red for uncompleted or inadequate – and watch the impact on the kids. Like us adults, children often judge their own progress against their peers. Closing the information gap so that the children can easily make that judgement should help to increase competitiveness and motivation
10. Students make their own assessments – set up two trays at the front of the class. When pupils have finished a piece of work ask them to come up and place it in one of the trays. Explain to them that one of the trays is for work they deem to be a good piece of work and the other tray is for a piece of work they deem to be poor. Most of us would tend to be modest the first time around and place our work in the ‘poor’ tray (even if we didn’t necessarily believe  it belonged there!). However, next lesson the pupils will know what to expect and will be keen to produce a better piece of work to be able to justify placing the work in the ‘good’ tray