Monday, 10 February 2014

Learning to Code vs Learning Computer Science (Terence Eden's Blog)



It's always very tricky when people who aren't educators start banging on about what should or shouldn't be taught in schools. My own school days are but a hazy memory of hormones, angst, and boring homework. Yet here I am, pontificating.
With the current "fad" of encouraging children to learn to code, I thought I would be worth looking at the difference between coding and computer science.
 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0

History

I learned the infamous Logo Turtle at school and BBC BASIC at home. That is learning to code. I followed instructions, copy-typed from books, and made minor adjustments to "personalise" my programs.
At A-Level I started studying "Decision Mathematics". Rather than esoteric calculus, and prosaic formulas, it looks at how to solve problems logically. It was the perfect primer for learning how to become a programmer and I firmly believe that no conversation about teaching coding in schools is complete without a theoretical understanding of the science behind the code.

An Example

This is an exercise I run through with people wanting to understand the basics of computer science:
Sort the following numbers:
7, 8, 1, 3, 2, 7, 6
Easy enough to do in your head, no?
Ok - explain to me how you did it?
We then talk through what we think the problem is - in what way do we want the numbers sorted? High to low? Low to high? Alphabetical? What, in fact, do we want to do with the sorted numbers?
What series of very simple instructions could we give to an absolute idiot such that they could follow them and get the right answer?
Where are the "gotchas"? If two numbers are the same, how should they be sorted? Does it matter?
Are there more or less efficient ways to sort numbers? Are there times when less efficiency is good?
Hey presto - we've begun to explore Computer Science. We can craft algorithms, learn how and why they are important, write out pseudo-code, hunt for bugs.

Learning To Code

The above is a great introduction to Computer Science. Now let's look at what learning to code teaches people.
  1. sort([7, 8, 1, 3, 2, 7, 6]);
Or, perhaps
  1. var numbers = [7, 8, 1, 3, 2, 7, 6];
  2. numbers.sort();
What has that taught anyone? Merely syntax.
I learned the BASIC and Pascal languages at school. Who uses those now? No one. Learning to code an iPhone or Android app is great fun - but in 10 years time when those children are adults, the world will have moved on and Objective C will be yet another obsolete language.
Yes, learning the rudiments of one language can be helpful in picking up another - but it's no substitute for understanding the fundamentals of why you are doing something.
That's why I'm a big supporter of the Apps For Good initiative. Rather than just teaching kids how to build an Android app, it takes them through the process of design, user research, competitor analysis, testing, monetizing, building a team, and legal / social ramifications of releasing an app. All of which are vital tools to any would-be programmer.
It's not just about learning which buttons to press in order to make an app - it's about a deeper understanding.

if ($thou >= $summers_day) {$darling_buds.winds($rough, $shake);}

Let's put it in language the humanities graduates can understand.
Learning to code is merely teaching people to spell.
Computer Science is about what makes a poem beautiful, why alliteration is alluring, how iambic pentameter unlocks the secrets of Shakespeare.
That is what I think we need to be teaching.


Friday, 31 January 2014

Critical Questions for CS Education Research


original article http://blog.acm.org/archives/csta/2013/11/critical_questi.html


  • What are the indicators of incoming student success in introductory level computer science in colleges and universities?
  • Does computer science learning in high schools contribute to success/improvement in other disciplines, especially mathematics and science?
  • What is the link between age/educational development and the potential to learn and master computer science concepts?
  • Are there issues of ergonomics in the introduction of computing devices with young children?
  • Is there a link between previous math learning and success in computer science at the high school level?
  • What are the major factors that lead to students making early choices not to pursue computer science?
  • What is the role of informal education programs in scaffolding learning in computer science, especially in communities where access to computer science learning in school is limited?
  • What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of MOOCs in middle school and high school student learning?
  • What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of MOOCs for the professional development of computer science teachers?
  • What models professional development are most effective for improving teacher mastery of computer science concepts and pedagogy?
  • What are the impacts of current efforts to market computer science to students?
  • To what extent do poverty and lack of home access to computer science tools impact computer science performance and or interest in school?
  • Do one-to-one devices per child programs have any impact on computer science interest or performance?
  • What are the major factors in computer science teacher retention?
  • What is required to increase the availability of teacher preparation programs for computer science teachers?
  • What is the impact of transitioning the the content of teacher preparation courses in "educational technology/AV" to a focus on computational thinking across STEM?
  • What is the ideal balance between content knowledge learning and pedagogical learning in computer science teacher preparation and alternative certifications?
  • Do hybrid programs (educators and volunteer partnerships) improve student access to rigorous computer science courses and increase the pool of well-prepared computer science teachers?

  • Which of these do you think is most important?
    And what have we missed?
    Chris Stephenson
    CSTA Executive Director

    Comments

    I am a computer science/mathematics teacher at Fenwick High School in Oak Park, IL. I am also pursuing a PhD in mathematics education part-time at Illinois Institute of Technology. Currently, I am working on developing questions for my Qualifying Exam. I would like to include a computer science component (or maybe even make it the focus) in my research. I am only just beginning my quest and I was wondering if anyone out there has an opinion about research papers that I absolutely need to read or maybe just some good archival sites that I need to know about. I couldn't believe my luck to find this list that you've made up here. I think I want to start to get in on the dialogue.
    Take a look at what has happened to toys over the past 20 years or so. Open-play toys, like Legos, have become increasingly specialized.
    Where are the open-play apps for computers? In the 1980s, those were the built-in programming environments that made it easy to tinker and let your imagination run wild. Now, on tablets, all you can really do is download pre-built, one-size apps.
    Is the lack of easily accessible development environments having an impact on computer science interest?
    The two main questions I would ask before any of these are:
    1. What is the most powerful conception of "computer science" that we could imagine and then figure out how to teach?
    2. What are the "developmentally best" versions of these ideas (cf Papert, and Bruner) for each developmental level from K-12?
    The first question addresses the weak and inadequate characterizations of computing in the current reform attempts. In a field that is still inventing itself (and whose current state is not well developed) we need to "teach for learning and change" to help bring our field to the better states it needs to assume in the 21st century.
    The second re-asks the serious questions that Papert asked about mathematics and computing (and that Bruner asked about learning and teaching in general). The basic idea is that what is actually important about a field should not be removed in a child's version, but an intellectually honest child's version may require new inventions to serve both the needs of the subject and the child. The first question has to be partially well answered before the second one can be addressed at the level needed.
    I make these comments because I take the term "education" seriously, and think of it as being more than just vocational training that addresses perceived needs by employers.
    How do we define "computer science"? From the context in the questions it looks like CS and programming are being use interchangeability. Is this the intent. If it is, fine. If it is not, not so fine. My question always is "What is CS at the high school level?"
    One additional question:
    What are the best model(s) for connecting and supporting high school computing teachers given the usual state of isolation?

    Thursday, 30 January 2014

    Strategies for stretching your most able students

    Senior leader Laura Grainger discusses her project to improve the attainment of high-ability students, including a specific focus on year 11 and encouraging every child to aim for an A grade in at least one GCSE.

    General-Achievement.gif
    Fulham Cross Girls School is in a relatively affluent area but as is the case in west London boroughs, there is a significant divide between rich and poor.
    Local schools often have high numbers of pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds, and we have 85 per cent of students with English as an additional language. But that’s not to say we are struggling; we have been Ofsted outstanding since 2008 and 70 per cent of our students achieve five or more GCSEs at A* to C, including English and maths.
    Before Fulham Cross, I was a middle leader who wanted to have more of a whole-school impact, so I applied for the Future Leaders headship development programme and as a result joined Fulham Cross’s seniorleadership team in September 2012.
    In consultation with the head of school, I began looking at areas for improvement, and spotted that the number of students getting A and A*s had decreased over three consecutive years. Key stage 2 data projections suggested our 2013 GCSE results would include only 13 A/A* grades.
    So I set out to reverse this trend, with a target of 30 per cent of grades being either an A or an A* in summer 2013. This would happen by increasing the level of challenge across the curriculum and by developing a programme of enrichment for targeted students.

    Making waves

    One of the reasons for falling A grades was that our students are really polite, hard-working girls who produce pages of notes but can be quite passive, and don’t always say if they haven’t understood.
    There were three layers to my work and I based it on the “waves” model of intervention:
    1. Increasing challenge across the school.
    2. Establishing a Challenge Club to push the top achieving students.
    3. Establishing one-to-one mentoring for students in the Challenge Club.
    My work began with a whole-school approach. I raised awareness of the importance of challenge in staff briefings, and developed their skills through toolboxes and INSET days. 
    I used data to demonstrate the need for change and appealed to the hearts and minds of staff, emphasising that our girls deserve the highest grades to give them an edge in higher education and the jobs market; that we should have the same level of challenge and rigour as top independent schools to help them compete. They are just as able and deserve the same opportunities.
    Staff INSET focused on teaching methods to facilitate this challenge, including De Bono’s six hats (a discussion and thinking tool), using thunks, and the introduction of a “challenge task” on all PowerPoint slides to enable students to take learning further. Departments have personalised this. For example, our geography department now has a “Geographical Genius” task on all slides, while religious studies has a “Philosopher’s Corner”.

    The Challenge Club

    There was no cohesive gifted and talented register, so I cross-referenced data for every student for every subject and consulted teachers to identify those who had potential but who were underperforming.
    The top 15 to 20 students per year group joined our new Challenge Club, an enrichment programme based around small group sessions on critical-thinking, higher order thinking skills, and how to progress to the highest grade.
    We also worked with the Brilliant Club, an organisation that gets PhD tutors into schools. Students developed research skills and wrote 2,000-word theses on philosophy or biology. Key stage 4 students also had A/A* sessions one lunchtime per week that focused on getting top grades in each subject. 
    In addition, every student had fortnightly 1:1 mentoring sessions with staff volunteers from across the school, from senior leadership team members to office staff. The meetings were designed to be challenging and focus on measurable outcomes. Students also had a Challenge Passport, a booklet that set out their academic targets as well as containing a series of challenges, competitions and extra-curricular activities that would develop thinking skills, as well as expanding social and cultural capital. Activities include researching the work of a philosopher, navigating the UCAS website, and completing extension activities in lessons.
    The aim was to be holistic by challenging not just their academic performance but also their view of themselves and their exposure to aspects of life that others take for granted. It might seem surprising, but there are some students who have never used the Tube or even gone into Central London. The aim of the mentoring was to encourage students to seek out opportunities beyond their comfort zones, from reading and writing a review of a little known Shakespeare play, to visiting the Spanish Institute, or going to the opera.

    Raising aspirations

    But the Challenge Club was not self-contained; the aim was to make it something that other students wanted to join and to show that challenge and work is something to aspire to, not avoid. 
    This involved making club members quite visible by giving them a special badge and a pink “Challenge Me” card. They would hold this up during lessons, making classroom differentiation more effective and clearly encouraging students to seek challenge. 
    Initially a few students used them less than constructively, but this was an opportunity to speak to those students about the responsibility that comes with being in the club, and emphasising that other students want to be a part of it and that they are role-models.
    Many other students are desperate to join the Challenge Club and I often urge them to get certain grades and I will consider it. It has proved a motivating factor for all students at Fulham Cross.

    The results?

    Results day last summer saw great outcomes; 75 per cent of students in year 11 got at least one A grade, 31 per cent of the total grades were A or A*s, and 29 per cent of students got five or more As. 
    As is always the case, this all required hard work from staff across the school, and not everything worked perfectly. I’ve developed ways to improve and expand this academic year, including targeting those year 7 and 10s who aren’t making enough progress. 
    We also run an intervention in partnership with an organisation called Spire Hub for those year 10s in the layer below Challenge Club, who entered with Level 5s but who are not currently on target to achieve five or more A/A* grades. This involves academic tutoring and aspiration work with university mentors and retired teachers. We are also doing further work with staff around levels of challenge in lessons and in the curriculum.
    As ever, the work’s impact on our students’ lives is best told anecdotally. One student in year 8 was severely disaffected and difficult to engage with, but despite her behavioural needs had high prior attainment. I began mentoring her, and it was clear that she was essentially in need of challenge and focus. As her mentor, I made it clear that the school had high expectations for her and that her behaviour mattered in the school community. It took time, but she rose to this challenge and has gone through real personal change. 
    Reflecting on my work on the Challenge Club, I can see that it has challenged me immensely – and that I am developing my own leadership skills as I work with colleagues and students. I am looking forward to this year, and seeing how my practice continues to be challenged and refined.
    • Laura Grainger is a member of the senior leadership team at Fulham Cross Girls School, a comprehensive in west London.

    Monday, 27 January 2014

    BETT: Can technology replace the classroom?

    BETT: Can technology replace the classroom?

    • 27 JAN 2014
    • BY IAN BAUCKHAM
    I visited the annual BETT education technology fair in London on Saturday and took part in a panel debate on whether the classroom, or the teacher, could or should be replaced by technological advances. BETT has been running for 30 years now. It more or less coincides therefore with my teaching career. When I think back to the BBC computers and floppy disks I knew back in the 80s the fair must have looked very different back then!
    Going round a fair like BETT, it is tempting to think that there is so much clever technology that surely the time is fast approaching when teachers will be superseded by computers. I think the reality is otherwise. And that's not just vested interests!
    It is stating the obvious to assert that technology is changing our homes, our workplaces, and the world. We all know about 3D printers, driverless cars, and the power of the smart phone as a dashboard for controlling every aspect of our lives. It's changing the economy, the way we work, live and, yes, think, as well.
    However, as a headteacher, when I look for good teaching, there isn't always a simple correlation between quality of teaching and learning on the one hand and, on the other, use of technology. Some excellent teaching I see uses ICT in only very simple ways. And some teaching, which on the surface tries to use ICT much more, turns out to be not particularly effective teaching, because students do not learn and progress as much as they might. In other words, lots of technology doesn't necessarily mean more or better learning.
    And on those occasions where you see really effective learning in a technology rich environment, what is it that makes it so effective? The answer to that, of course, is the mind and hand of the teacher in the design and concept, creating the best ethos for learning, taking students from where they are forwards in a way that is communicative and engaging.
    I think that all too often we look at what new technologies can do, and simply hang the latest device or software onto existing approaches to teaching - our rigid conceptions of what effective teaching strategies are. We can often be too easily wowed, seduced, by gimmickry, and in these cases the technology can actually become a barrier to learning, an obstacle in the relationship between student and teacher.
    That's why research tends to show that on average technological solutions to underachievement implemented on their own are relatively ineffective, compared with other approaches. How much money has been wasted over the past thirty years on technology that promised great things but never quite delivered?
    For me, good teaching and learning are about a dynamic, responsive and individualised partnershipbetween teacher and student, and, indeed, between students, something which social media increasingly facilitates.
    Communication technology has the power to enrich, democratise, individualise, extend, make more informal, flexible and responsive that learning partnership. It can accelerate learner autonomy, as long as necessary skills and knowledge are properly taught first, and student learning is properly monitored and steered. But, if the concept of good learning is poorly understood, or, indeed, if the teacher thinks the technology is replacing him or her, then the technology will be a cumbersome obstacle to learning, rather than an enabler of learning partnerships.
    So are either the classroom or the teacher doomed by the advance of technology? Well, the classroom will certainly change, and expand for some purposes outside its four walls. That's happening already. But school does have complementary functions, as well as just learning. Socialisation is one, and sadly refuge from chaotic and dysfunctional homes is all too often another. So there will be change, but both school and teacher will continue to be part of our social fabric.
    As Melinda Gates, wife of ‘Microsoft’ Bill, said recently:
    "Technology is just a tool. It’s a powerful tool. But it’s just a tool. Deep human connection is very different. It’s not a tool. It’s not a means to an end. It is the end – the purpose and the result of a meaningful life." (Melinda Gates 2013)
    In preparing for the BETT debate, I found Pearson’s excellent report ‘A rich seam’ published this week very thought provoking and exciting.

    Wednesday, 22 January 2014

    CRITICAL QUESTIONS FOR COMPUTER SCIENCE EDUCATION RESEARCH

    CRITICAL QUESTIONS FOR COMPUTER SCIENCE EDUCATION RESEARCH


    Over the past two years, we have seen wholesale reform of computing (and more specifically, computer science) education in the UK. In England from September 2014, a new national curriculum subject Computing, with a challenging and aspirational programme of study (“A high-quality computing education equips pupils to use computational thinking and creativity to understand and change the world.”) will replace ICT; in Scotland, we see Computing Science forming part of their Curriculum for Excellence; in Wales, September’s review of the ICT curriculum is shaping the ongoing Curriculum for Wales review; along with burgeoning activity in Northern Ireland.
    While there is a large corpus of computing education research, along with national and international policy reports, such as the ACM/CSTA’s Running on Empty (2010), the Royal Society’s Shut down or restart? report (2012) and ACM Europe’s informatics education report (2013), there still remain a number of critical questions in computer science education. The recent announcement of the UK Forum for Computing Education provides an opportunity to support this important research agenda. Further to a group discussion led by members of the CSTA at a recent ACM Education Council meeting, the following list of questions cover a breadth of issues and reflect the deep need for further research-grounded solutions to the issues we face.
    • What are the indicators of incoming student success in introductory level computer science in colleges and universities?
    • Does computer science learning in schools contribute to success/improvement in other disciplines, especially mathematics and science?
    • What is the link between age/educational development and the potential to learn and master computer science concepts?
    • Are there issues of ergonomics in the introduction of computing devices with young children?
    • Is there a link between previous mathematics learning and success in computer science at school level?
    • What are the major factors that lead to students making early choices not to pursue computer science?
    • What is the role of informal education programs in scaffolding learning in computer science, especially in communities where access to computer science learning in school is limited?
    • What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of MOOCs in school student learning?
    • What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of MOOCs for the professional development of computer science teachers?
    • What models professional development are most effective for improving teacher mastery of computer science concepts and pedagogy?
    • What are the impacts of current efforts to market computer science to students?
    • To what extent do poverty and lack of home access to computer science tools impact computer science performance and or interest in school?
    • Do one-to-one devices per child programs have any impact on computer science interest or performance?
    • What are the major factors in computer science teacher retention?
    • What is required to increase the availability of teacher preparation programs for computer science teachers?
    • What is the impact of transitioning the the content of teacher preparation courses in “educational technology/AV” to a focus on computational thinking across STEM?
    • What is the ideal balance between content knowledge learning and pedagogical learning in computer science teacher preparation and alternative certifications?
    • Do hybrid programs (educators and volunteer partnerships) improve student access to rigorous computer science courses and increase the pool of well-prepared computer science teachers?
    Which of these do you think is most important? And what is missing? (the questions are listed in no particular order and have been labelled alphabetical for easy referencing in the comments)

    Monday, 20 January 2014

    Research Insights: Evidence-based best practice from SecEd & NFER


    From improving staff engagement and student happiness, to preventing NEETs or running a Pupil Premium Summer School, the SecEd-NFER Research Insights articles offer a wealth of evidence-based, best practice and advice. All 11 articles published to date are now available in a free PDF.

    SecEd-NFER11.gif
    A partnership between SecEd and the NFER has seen the publication of an ongoing series of research-based articles offering practical and useful advice and information to help schools improve outcomes in key areas.
    The latest article, published in January 2014, focuses on measuring and promoting/improving the happiness of your students and what this can do for our overall outcomes. The article also looks at how schools can promote staff engagement and satisfaction.
    This free PDF download includes all 11 NFER/SecEd Research Insightsarticles to date tackling topics such as effective alcohol education, Pupil Premium Summer Schools, computer games in the classroom, teaching 21st century skills, creativity, promoting healthy eating, preventing NEETs, self-evaluation and more.
    To download the free PDF, click the link above or visit our Supplements page:www.sec-ed.co.uk/supplements